The disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie continues to grip the nation, especially after multiple ransom notes surfaced demanding $6 million for her return. However, a former senior FBI official is now questioning whether the case fits the profile of a true kidnapping. The search for the missing mother of “Today” co-anchor Savannah Guthrie has entered its second week. Investigators have canvassed the Tucson-area neighborhood, collected nearly 20,000 tips, and reviewed home surveillance footage while the family continues to plead publicly for her safe return.

A troubling development came with a third ransom message reportedly sent to TMZ, claiming the sender was “not being taken seriously.” Former FBI Assistant Director Chris Swecker expressed strong skepticism, suggesting public platforms can attract opportunists and distract investigators. He warned the ransom communications could be a scam rather than evidence of a genuine abduction.

Swecker noted that real kidnappers typically provide clear proof of life — such as a recent photo, video, or audio — to ensure payment. No verified evidence confirming Nancy’s condition has been released, deepening doubts about the authenticity of the ransom demands. He suggested a third party may be exploiting the high-profile case.

Meanwhile, the emotional toll on the family remains visible. Authorities have intensified efforts, doubling the reward for information and analyzing doorbell camera footage that revealed new identifying details about a possible suspect. Whether the case involves a kidnapping, a hoax, or something else entirely remains uncertain, but as days pass without answers, concern continues to grow.