Iron-rich water is another silent culprit, especially in homes with well water. Even city water with aging pipes can leave rusty freckles after repeated washes. Add to that certain hair products, self-tanners, or “warmth-enhancing” shampoos that transfer pigment even when your hair feels dry, and the mystery deepens. Cleaning sprays with hidden bleach or peroxide can also cause the exact same “stain,” without you realizing you’ve sprayed your towels.

The fix starts with prevention: keep white towels for skincare, wait for products to dry before contact, filter your water if it’s high in iron, and use old towels for hair coloring or pigmented shampoos. Learn to read the mark — big irregular splotches usually mean bleaching; small scattered dots often signal minerals. Once benzoyl peroxide or bleach damage happens, it’s permanent. In those cases, I either dye the towel darker, repurpose it for cleaning, or bleach the whole thing for a fresh, uniform look. Since learning this, I’ve gone from losing towels every few months to maybe one a year — and I never look at an “orange stain” the same way again.